Back to review · Raw Markdown · Review pack (HTML)

InfraFabric External Review Pack — Single File

This is a single-file bundle intended for review environments that cannot reliably fetch multiple URLs.

Links

Alternate host mirror (same paths)

Review instructions (portable)

Hard rules:

  1. 100% factual: every non-trivial claim must be tagged [SOURCE]/[REVIEW]/[TRACE]/[INFERENCE]. If unverified, say “unverified” and stop.
  2. Vendor-neutral: critique deployment conditions + org behaviors, not vendor intent/competence.
  3. Mirror discipline: follow the review document’s section order; do not invent a new structure.

Deliverables: A) 5–10 bullets: what works / what doesn’t (tag each) B) Scorecard (0–5): mirror integrity, layout fidelity, humor discipline, mermaid value, if.trace demo value, CTA stealth C) Section-by-section critique (mirror headings): what’s mirrored, what’s missing, what feels templated/repeated D) Vendor-safe conclusion rewrite: success conditions / traps / questions-to-ask-vendor E) Unified diff patches against the current Dave bible (e.g., IF_DAVE_BIBLE_v2.0.md) and generator rules

if.trace receipt (portable extract)

{
  "id": "755ead27-f70b-4e22-beb4-5e4c190b94d3",
  "status": "done",
  "createdAt": "2026-01-10T00:00:00Z",
  "originalFilename": "if-intelligence-demo.md",
  "style": "if.intelligence.demo.v1",
  "sourceSha256": "82bb6a0c09ed7df868101586204e37e7725c9713e87553e2cbc668eff7097b68",
  "outputSha256": "c2241ebb59114c3bdd2f5da185a593d815571b2b56858809ab012404d61c2c5b",
  "warnings": ""
}

Review document (Markdown)

{
  "black_white": {
    "not_verified": [
      "Truth/correctness of any real-world claim beyond the provided evidence snapshot.",
      "Completeness of the registry relative to any private system or future roadmap."
    ],
    "verified": [
      "The output bytes match the receipt hash (when a receipt is published).",
      "The evidence sha256 values correspond to the bytes in the source bundle."
    ]
  },
  "created_at": "2026-01-10T00:00:00Z",
  "evidence": [
    {
      "bytes": 45110,
      "evidence_id": "R1",
      "path": "evidence/if.registry.json",
      "sha256": "2a65b8e8b82a897569ea675f51c4b72ea0c0bb962730d601289ade18423bd08a",
      "title": "Registry snapshot (product_id/path/status/kind/description)"
    }
  ],
  "findings": {
    "products": [
      {
        "description": "Integration inventory + adapters for external APIs. Active development; ready for integration review; no public runtime endpoints claimed.",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/api",
        "product_id": "if.api",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Auditable single- and multi-agent coordination surface: append-only task snapshots + signals, rendered to GET-first `/llm` views; controlled-writer updates; no-login review posture. Legacy name: `if.tasks` (keep legacy `/llm/platform/if-tasks/**` docs as an alias surface; canonical product id is `if.blackboard`).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/blackboard",
        "product_id": "if.blackboard",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Event/message backbone (runtime spec published; internal runtime exists). Public surfaces are specs + review packs; external reviewers cannot verify runtime liveness in real time (no public bus endpoints claimed).",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/bus",
        "product_id": "if.bus",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Evidence environment for agent work: artifacts (bytes + provenance), read plans, and derived artifacts with verification chains. Not a replacement for `if.bus` (control plane) or `if.trace` (integrity receipts).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/context",
        "product_id": "if.context",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Deterministic static discovery layer for public `/llm` surfaces (no query endpoints; client-side scoring; shardable index).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/discover",
        "product_id": "if.discover",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Wellbeing-aware interaction layer (non-clinical) and governance-seat outputs with explicit safety boundaries; live emo-social surface (public); not diagnosis/therapy; not compliance guarantees.",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/emotion",
        "product_id": "if.emotion",
        "status": "shipped"
      },
      {
        "description": "Governance packs (triage/decision/external challenge) bound to receipts; not compliance guarantees.",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/gov",
        "product_id": "if.gov",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Deliverable tier: council-style decision pack with risks/controls/eval plan, bound to receipts.",
        "kind": "sku",
        "path": "/if/gov/council",
        "product_id": "if.gov.council",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Deliverable tier: extended council pack + external challenge add-on (receipt-backed).",
        "kind": "sku",
        "path": "/if/gov/council/extended",
        "product_id": "if.gov.council.extended",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Deliverable tier: triage memo + receipt-backed decision framing (not a compliance guarantee).",
        "kind": "sku",
        "path": "/if/gov/triage",
        "product_id": "if.gov.triage",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Research orchestration module (roadmap only; no receipt-backed demo published yet).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/intelligence",
        "product_id": "if.intelligence",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Build-time developer knowledge base (KB) artifacts generated via `if.knowledge` (static Markdown/HTML; no runtime fetches). Preview: a bus/api KB snapshot is published; no deployed KB service on this host.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/kb",
        "product_id": "if.kb",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Build-time documentation pipeline (registry-driven; static Markdown/HTML; no runtime fetches). Preview: public knowledge-graph artifacts and review surfaces are published; no deployed runtime service is claimed on this host.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/knowledge",
        "product_id": "if.knowledge",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Machine-first, no-login evidence surface (txt-first) for sandboxed review: static `/llm` artifacts with stable breadcrumbs, verifiable bytes, and explicit black/white boundaries.",
        "kind": "surface",
        "path": "/llm",
        "product_id": "if.llm",
        "status": "shipped"
      },
      {
        "description": "Token-gated evidence surface for tenant/NDA artifacts (the `/mcp` wall). Public docs/specs live under `/llm/platform/mcp-*`.",
        "kind": "surface",
        "path": "/mcp",
        "product_id": "if.mcp",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Multi-pass investigation/research workflow module (formerly named `if.search`; roadmap only; no deployed service is claimed on this host).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/research",
        "product_id": "if.research",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Cross-cutting security posture for InfraFabric modules (signals + evidence-typed actuation + containment mapping). Roadmap only; no deployed security runtime on this host.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/security",
        "product_id": "if.security",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Receipt-backed secrets detection (audit mode, redacted outputs). Preview demo exists; not CI-integrated or 'live'.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/security/secrets/detect",
        "product_id": "if.security.secrets.detect",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Narrative red-team publishing/review UI that makes if.trace legible via dossiers/packs and routes reviewers to receipts. Legacy label: ShadowRT.",
        "kind": "surface",
        "path": "/review/shadowrt",
        "product_id": "if.shadowrt",
        "status": "shipped"
      },
      {
        "description": "Tooling/skills catalog for compatible clients: GET-only `/llm/skills` index plus dated review packs for byte verification and discovery.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/llm/skills",
        "product_id": "if.skills",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Narrative logging protocol module (vector vs bitmap). Protocol artifacts are live (story pack + vector logging); no deployed runtime on this host.",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/story",
        "product_id": "if.story",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Multi-agent/swarm execution module (roadmap only; no receipt-backed demo published yet).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/if/swarm",
        "product_id": "if.swarm",
        "status": "roadmap"
      },
      {
        "description": "Public receipt surface (hashes; signatures only when present and verifiable). Proof of bytes/integrity, not correctness.",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/trace",
        "product_id": "if.trace",
        "status": "shipped"
      },
      {
        "description": "Deterministic document CI (lint \u2192 render HTML/PDF \u2192 QA) for review-proof packs.",
        "kind": "product",
        "path": "/if/typeset",
        "product_id": "if.typeset",
        "status": "preview"
      },
      {
        "description": "Audit-grade documentation bible: canonical scaffolding for /llm packs (black/white boundaries, one-URL-per-line, patch-first iteration, and the Jester line rule).",
        "kind": "module",
        "path": "/llm/platform/if-whitepapers-bible",
        "product_id": "if.whitepapers.bible",
        "status": "shipped"
      }
    ],
    "status_counts": {
      "preview": 12,
      "roadmap": 8,
      "shipped": 5
    }
  },
  "inquiry": "What products exist in the current registry, and what are their statuses (black/white)?",
  "notes": {
    "integrity": "see if.trace receipt for output bytes",
    "live_lookup": false
  },
  "schema_id": "if.intelligence.demo.report",
  "schema_version": "demo.v1",
  "steps": [
    {
      "step_id": "intake",
      "summary": "Capture inquiry and constraints."
    },
    {
      "step_id": "evidence_inventory",
      "summary": "Inventory evidence inputs with sha256 and sizes."
    },
    {
      "step_id": "extraction",
      "summary": "Extract registry snapshot: product_id/path/status/kind/description."
    },
    {
      "step_id": "report",
      "summary": "Emit a black/white report: what is observed vs not claimed."
    }
  ]
}